WINTER HAVEN, FL — Brian Motley, 40, is wanted for manslaughter after what police are calling an altercation at a Winter Haven bar left a 40-year-old Polk City man dead. According to the Winter Haven Police Department, an arrest warrant has been issued for Motley following the death of Adam Chism, who never regained consciousness after being punched during the incident early Sunday morning.
The incident occurred on October 18, 2026, at approximately 1:47 a.m. at Caribbean Bay, located at 1004 Lake Howard Drive in Winter Haven. Police say Motley and Chism were involved in a verbal dispute when Motley punched Chism once, knocking him unconscious and causing him to fall to the ground.
Chism was rushed to a local hospital, where he remained unconscious despite efforts by first responders and medical staff. He succumbed to his injuries on Wednesday, October 21.
Police also reported that Motley battered a second adult while fleeing the scene. That individual was not injured. Motley remains wanted and faces charges of manslaughter and felony battery upon his arrest.
“Our prayers and sympathies are with Adam’s family and friends as they try to navigate through this senseless tragedy,” said Winter Haven Police Chief Vance Monroe. “We ask for the public’s help in locating Brian Motley and quickly bringing him to justice.”
Anyone with information regarding Motley’s whereabouts is urged to contact Winter Haven Detective Nikki Ellegard at 863-255-3998 or the Winter Haven Police Department at 863-401-2256.
Anonymous tips can be submitted to Heartland Crime Stoppers at 1-888-400-TIPS (8477). Information leading to an arrest may qualify for a cash reward. Nothing further at this time.
SOURCE: WINTER HAVEN POLICE
