On June 17, 2025, Polk County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded to an anonymous complaint about two deceased dogs at a residence on West 6th Street in Frostproof. Deputies contacted 20-year-old Nashali Santiago, who stated she was caring for the dogs while her brother was deployed overseas.
In the backyard, deputies found two deceased German Shepherds, identified by Santiago as “Ajax,” a 3-year-old male, and “Sugar,” a 2-year-old female, inside a makeshift pen with no roof or shade. The outdoor temperature was 93 degrees Fahrenheit. The pen had no food or water bowls, and both dogs were in early stages of decomposition.
Santiago reported last seeing the dogs the previous night, claiming they were fine. She stated she typically fed and watered them once daily in the evening.
The dogs were sent to the University of Florida Veterinary Diagnostic Laboratory, where Dr. Adam Stern, a Board-Certified Veterinary Pathologist, conducted forensic necropsies. Results confirmed both dogs died from heatstroke and dehydration. Ajax was malnourished, with inadequate feeding cited as the cause, not illness. Sugar was in normal body condition but had not eaten recently. No signs of disease or injury were found.
Santiago was arrested and charged with two counts of felony animal cruelty (F3). Sheriff Grady Judd stated the case involved neglect, emphasizing the obligation to properly care for animals.
Editor’s Note: Nashali Santiago was located and arrested on September 16, 2025.
Source: Polk County Sheriff’s Office
